I Bond confusion: Understanding how the 0.0% rate rolls out

Back on May 1, I wrote an article about how the new  I Bond inflation adjusted variable rate had fallen into the deep negative, -1.60% (annualized). And this meant any Series I Savings Bond with a fixed rate of  1.6% or less would pay 0.0% for six months.

Since then several readers have commented that they aren’t seeing the 0.0% rate in the Savings Bond Wizard. Others have cursed me and told me I have it all wrong, believing that the fixed rate is ‘fixed’ and can never be reduced. Others are just confused.

If you use the Treasury’s Savings Bond Wizard, you are going to see some misleading numbers for awhile, but they aren’t wrong. (I love the Wizard, by the way, it is an excellent tool.) If you have it, open it up today and get the latest update, which provides interest rates through November 2015.

But first, read this …

How is that rate calculated? The Treasury Direct site has a lot of great information on I Bonds, including a very good Rates & Terms page. This chart showing the I Bond rate formula is drawn from that page:

I Bond formulaOK, it’s obvious if the fixed rate is 0.0% and the inflation rate is negative, the composite rate is going to drop to 0.0%, the lowest possible. But what if your fixed rate is 3.0%, as it was back in the good old days (May to November 2001)? What will happen to your fixed rate under that formula? Here is the calculation:

[0.0300 + (2 x -0.0080) + (0.0300 x -0.0080)]
[0.0300 + -0.0160 + – 0.00024]
resulting in a composite rate of 1.38%

So, according to the Treasury formula, your fixed rate will be lowered by the negative inflation rate. It will result in a composite rate of 1.38% for six months.

But … my Savings Bond Wizard shows a higher rate! It might, and it isn’t wrong. The I Bond composite rate rolls out across six months, depending on the month when you first bought the I Bond. The Treasury has another nice chart that shows this:

I Bond rate rolloutSo the Savings Bond Wizard will continue to show a higher rate, based on the last period’s 1.48% variable rate, until the new rate kicks in – depending on the month when you first bought the I Bond. If you bought an I Bond in October 2003, the new rate will begin in October 2015 and continue for six months. If you bought in November 2003, the new rate started May 1 and will continue for six months.

I have updated my Savings Bond Wizard and here is what is it showing for May 2015 and November 2015 for the I Bonds I currently own:

May November

FYI: Rate is the current six-month composite rate, yield is the annualized yield over the lifetime of the I Bond.

That is almost crystal clear, isn’t it? As the new composite rate rolls out over the next six months, all my I Bonds will be affected by the -1.6% variable rate, and the yield – the annualized interest paid over the life of the I Bond – will also decline.

Take a look at the two I Bonds issued in October 2001. They have a fixed rate of 3.0% (nice!) and so they fit the formula that I posted above:

[0.0300 + (2 x -0.0080) + (0.0300 x -0.0080)]
[0.0300 + -0.0160 + – 0.00024]
resulting in a composite rate of 1.38%

If you look at the November 2015 rate, it is 1.38%.

And another thing. I am totally, 100% recommending hanging on to all your I Bonds through this six months of reduced returns. Inflation fell at an annual rate of -1.60% from September 2014 to March 2015. Even if you are getting a return of 0.0%, you are beating inflation by 1.6%. You’ll survive.

Because you can buy only $10,000 per person in I Bonds each calendar year (plus the IRS refund trick), they are an asset to hold. I Bonds are part of a strategy of pushing inflation-protected, tax-deferred money into the future. The only reason to sell them is if you need the cash right now.

I hope this helps clear up some of the confusion circling around I Bonds in these strange months of post-deflation 2015.

About Tipswatch

Author of Tipswatch.com blog, David Enna is a long-time journalist based in Charlotte, N.C. A past winner of two Society of American Business Editors and Writers awards, he has written on real estate and home finance, and was a founding editor of The Charlotte Observer's website.
This entry was posted in Investing in TIPS. Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to I Bond confusion: Understanding how the 0.0% rate rolls out

  1. tipswatch says:

    Marty, in the Savings Bond Wizard there is a setting in the upper left corner with the title: ‘Price for’ … You can change that to a future date.

  2. Marty says:

    How do I get the display out of SBW you show after this line…
    “I have updated my Savings Bond Wizard and here is what is it showing for May 2015 and November 2015 for the I Bonds I currently own:”

  3. David Michael says:

    Unbelieveable! I just found you, your articles and blog as a result of Seeking Alpha. Finally, someone who understands I-Bonds. Having a number of I-bonds dated back to August 2001 with 3.0 fixed rate, I was quite content with the 4-5% interest rates. Then…swoosh…1.38%. What the heck? I sent three emails to Treasury with no response, called them and held on for three hours with no human on the other end. Maybe everybody is too busy searching Hillary’s emails. If that happened in my own company I would have fired the whole lot of them. How frustrating.

    Finally, you have provided the answer to what is going on. I thought my 3.0 fixed rate was as low it would go. Now I see differently. It took about 13 years for the Bonds to double. Safe but slow, slow returns. Thank goodness we just let the value add up.

    I’d say this…I like having the I-Bonds as a base support for our investments. But most of all, I love our dividend paying stocks even better. Many pay as much as 10% a year and keep growing.

    In summary…many thanks for a fine blog and series of excellent articles. As someone suggested the Treasury should hire you to write a monthly column. Obviously, Treasury doesn’t give a rip about us I-Bond owners. Heads need to roll in that government organization, such as it is.

  4. Dee Louis says:

    Just checked the Nov. 2015 SBW update and was puzzled. I googled my concern and found your site. Great explanation of what’s occurring.
    Where does the government “shop” to experience negative inflation. They obviously don’t include “discretionary” items like taxes, utilities, insurance, healthcare expenses, education, etc in their calculations.

  5. Tom Jones says:

    Good job! I have two $10,000 I-bonds from the good old days. :>)

  6. tipswatch says:

    Tim, the 3% fixed rate does not appear in the Wizard, just the current composite rate, which will be 1.38% once the -1.60% inflation-adjusted rate is subtracted from the fixed rate, according to the formula.
    [0.0300 + (2 x -0.0080) + (0.0300 x -0.0080)]
    [0.0300 + -0.0160 + – 0.00024]
    resulting in a composite rate of 1.38%

  7. tim says:

    “Take a look at the two I Bonds issued in October 2001. They have a fixed rate of 3.0% “…I don’t see the 3% annualized yield in the Wizard Table. Will you please break that down further?

  8. Len says:

    Excellent exposition, as usual. Treasury should put you on the payroll. However as time goes by I become less and less confident that the determining factor (CPI-U) is remotely related to the expenses of someone in retirement, or just living off their investments.

  9. Matthew Poskonka says:

    Love your articles – keep up the good work.
    Matthew Poskonka

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s