If you are looking to invest in the July 21 auction of a 10-year Treasury Inflation-Protected Security, and you haven’t bought US Savings I Bonds this year, my advice is: Stop right there and read this.
I Bonds are the better investment right now. It’s a slam dunk when you compare an I Bond to a 5-year TIPS. The I Bond pays you the rate of inflation over the next five years, and then you can sell it without penalty. A 5-year TIPS has a real yield of negative 0.620%.
Would you rather have a bond paying the inflation rate, or a 5-year TIPS paying the inflation rate minus 0.62%. Easy choice.
Comparing an I Bond with a 10-year TIPS is a little more complicated.
THE CASE FOR I BONDS
Right now, looking at current yields (July 11), a 10-year TIPS is paying a real return of 0.549%. So with a 10-year TIPS, you get a 0.549% premium over an I Bond. Advantage TIPS.
The problem with that equation is that 10-year TIPS traditionally pay a 1% premium, or more, over I Bonds. There are good reasons for that:
1) I Bonds have a tax advantage. Your interest compounds and your principal base continues to grow over the 30-year life of the the I Bond. But you never have to pay income tax on that growth until you sell the I Bond. A disadvantage of TIPS is that the inflation adjustment to principal is taxable in the year it was earned. So you ‘prepay’ that tax until maturity.
(Both I Bonds and TIPS are protected against state income taxes, by the way.)
2) I Bonds can be sold after five years, with no penalty. (But income tax becomes due when you sell, so the tax advantage disappears at that point.) I Bonds give you flexiblity. If rates are more attractive five years from now, sell and buy the new issue, or a bank CD, or TIPS or just go on a cruise.
3) Record-keeping with I Bonds is much easier. Download the Savings Bond Wizard and enter your info. When the time comes, sell the I Bonds. Pay the tax. Simple.
TIPS are more complicated, and if you ever tried to navigate the TreasuryDirect.gov site to log your interest payments and principal adjustments, you will know what I mean. There are no ‘simple’ reports on TreasuryDirect. You are even on your own to seek out and download tax statements. The government won’t mail them to you.
I Bonds are pointed at small investors. Each year, you can only buy $5,000 at TreasuryDirect.gov and $5,000 in paper I Bonds, per one Social Security number. That would mean a couple could buy $20,000 a year in I Bonds. Still, the thought of two TreasuryDirect accounts and paper I Bonds sitting in a safe-deposit box … tires me out.
(Update 7/13/11: From Bloomberg: The Treasury Department will halt sales of paper U.S. savings bonds as of January through banks and other financial institutions to reduce costs by about $70 million over the next five years.)
With I Bonds, right now, you are getting the rate of inflation, nothing more. That means you are probably looking at a five-year investment, then selling them, paying the tax and reinvesting into TIPS or better-yielding I Bonds or CDs. They don’t look like a good long-term investment.
Yes, I Bonds are a flawed investment, but they are also the best super-safe investment around right now. They protect you against inflation. They defer your taxes. They can be sold after five years.
For the super-safe portion of your portfolio, I think the first $5,000 you invest should be in I Bonds (or $10,000 or $20,000 if you are willing to endure the pain of two TreasuryDirect accounts and paper holdings) .
After you do that, go ahead and take a look at the 10-year TIPs being issued July 21.
I’ll probably pass on that one, though.
Nice respond in return of this question with real arguments and
telling the whole thing about that.
Pingback: I Bonds: The paper version is fading away in 2012 | Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities