Do AI innovations signal the end to human journalism? Let’s take a look.
And now, for something completely different on a Saturday morning, I asked Bing.com’s new ChatGPT-powered software to write an article on January inflation, in the style of Tipswatch.com. I gave it no more information. The top headline was written by Bing; the links you see in the article were created by Bing. And here we go:
By Bing
The latest inflation report for January showed that consumer prices rose 6.4% from a year ago, slightly higher than economists’ expectations. This was mainly driven by increases in food, energy and housing costs. The core inflation rate, which excludes food and energy, was 6% (wrong; it was 5.6%), also above forecasts.
These numbers indicate that inflation remains elevated and persistent, despite some signs of moderation in recent months. The Federal Reserve has acknowledged this challenge and has signaled its intention to raise interest rates several times this year to combat inflationary pressures. However, some Fed officials have also expressed caution about tightening monetary policy too quickly or too much, given the uncertainty about the pandemic and its impact on economic activity.
So what does this mean for your savings? If you are holding cash or low-yielding fixed-income investments, you are losing purchasing power every month as inflation erodes your real returns. To protect your savings from inflation, you may want to consider investing in Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS), which adjust their principal and interest payments based on changes in the Consumer Price Index (CPI).
TIPS are currently offering attractive real yields across all maturities, ranging from 1.60% to 1.80% (wrong; current range is 1.45% to 1.55%). This means that you can lock in a positive return above inflation for up to 30 years with TIPS. Moreover, TIPS also offer tax advantages if you hold them in tax-deferred accounts such as IRAs or 401(k)s.
Another option to hedge against inflation is to buy Series I Savings Bonds (I Bonds), which also pay interest based on changes in CPI but have some additional features that make them more flexible than TIPS. For example, I Bonds have no maturity date (wrong; it is 30 years) and can be redeemed anytime after one year without penalty (except for three months’ interest if redeemed within five years). They also have a maximum purchase limit of $10,000 per person per year and are exempt from state and local income taxes.
The current composite rate for I Bonds issued from November 2022 to April 2023 is an impressive 9.6% (wrong; it is 6.89%), which consists of a fixed rate of 0% (wrong; it is 0.4%) plus a variable rate of 9.54% (wrong; it is 6.48%) based on CPI data from September 2022. However, this rate will change every six months depending on new CPI data released by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Based on current projections, the variable rate for I Bonds issued from May 2023 to October 2023 could drop significantly to around 3.5%.
Therefore, if you are interested in buying I Bonds at their current high rate, you may want to act soon before they reset in May. You can buy I Bonds online through TreasuryDirect.gov or through payroll deduction plans offered by some employers.
In summary, January inflation was higher than expected and poses a risk to your savings if you don’t take steps to protect them from losing value over time. TIPS and I Bonds are two options that can help you preserve your purchasing power and earn positive real returns amid high inflation.
— End of Bing article —
Reaction
If you want to compare, you can go back and look at my original article on January inflation, from which Bing “borrowed” information without linking to the actual article. (It did link to my Inflation and I Bonds page, however.) My article includes helpful charts, something Bing lacks at this point.
Bing’s writing style is crisp and clear, with no spelling errors — certainly in the style of Tipswatch.com! I like that it expanded the topic from January inflation to focus on its effect on your savings and then suggest I Bonds and TIPS as a possible solution.
Bing made some puzzling errors. Where did it get a core inflation rate of 6.0% instead of the actual 5.6%? And it ran into serious problems when it tried to explain the current variable rate and fixed rate of I Bonds issued through the end of April. The answer was right there on the page it was referencing:
I Bonds purchased from November 2022 through April 2023 will pay an inflation-adjusted annual rate of 6.48%, and when combined with a fixed rate of 0.4%, creates an annualized composite rate of 6.89% for six months.
Overall, this attempt was a fail. However, it probably would have gotten a B in a college freshman econ class. Think the professor would have caught those mistakes?
Crosschecking with Google search
Was Bing’s incorrect information too difficult to find? Let’s see how Google search does with these specific questions:
What was the January core inflation rate?
Answer: 5.6%. Correct.
What is the maturity date of an I Bond?
Answer: 30 years. Correct.
What is the current real yield of a 30-year TIPS?
Answer: 1.63%. That was correct on Thursday, but Friday’s close was 1.49%, based on Treasury estimates.
What is the current I Bond composite rate?
Answer: 6.89%. Correct.
What is the current I Bond fixed rate?
Answer: Nothing specific, but does link to correct page on TreasuryDirect.
What is the current I Bond variable rate:
Answer: Nothing specific, same link as above.
What is Bing Chat?
Bing is Microsoft’s search engine and it has gotten a lot of attention in recent weeks as it began rolling out its artificial intelligence chat feature, which can answer questions in expanded (and possibly thoughtful) discussions.
Microsoft calls this “your AI-powered copilot for the web.” It says these features are all powered by an upgraded version of GPT 3.5, the OpenAI language model that powers ChatGPT.
I asked Bing how it is powered and it responded:
Bing chat is powered by a combination of natural language processing, machine learning and artificial intelligence technologies. These technologies enable me to understand your messages, generate relevant responses and learn from your feedback. I’m always trying to improve my skills and knowledge.
Microsoft calls its version of the AI software the “Prometheus model,” apparently named after the Greek god who gave humans fire (and thus, technology). Of course, a quick search with Bing would show that Prometheus is also a 2012 film, the fifth installment in the Alien franchise. It’s a horror film about an android with a high level of artificial intelligence.
My feedback is that Bing wrote a convincingly authentic article with several major errors. It still needs work, but … whether we like it or not … it marks a step toward a complex and possibly confusing future.
* * *
Feel free to post comments or questions below. If it is your first-ever comment, it will have to wait for moderation. After that, your comments will automatically appear.Please stay on topic and avoid political tirades.
David Enna is a financial journalist, not a financial adviser. He is not selling or profiting from any investment discussed. I Bonds and TIPS are not “get rich” investments; they are best used for capital preservation and inflation protection. They can be purchased through the Treasury or other providers without fees, commissions or carrying charges. Please do your own research before investing.






















On Schwab, I try to either take a screenshot of the buy order page before I submit the order, or…